Pennsylvania v. Smyrnes

This was a capital direct appeal arising out of Appellant Ricky Smyrnes' participation, with a group of five other individuals, in the kidnapping, torture, and murder of Jennifer Lee Daugherty. The case was a companion one to that of co-perpetrator Melvin Knight. Appellant forced the victim to write a staged suicide note, after which Appellant and Knight dragged her to the bathroom; Knight repeatedly and fatally stabbed her; Appellant slit her wrists (albeit superficially); Appellant and Knight choked her as she lay dying; and her body was placed in a trash can. Appellant and Knight moved the can and body outside to a remote location, where these were discovered the next day. Apparently in light of developing evidence that a disturbance had occurred in Appellant’s apartment, police began to interview the co-perpetrators, and inculpatory statements were obtained. At the penalty hearing, the Commonwealth pursued, and the jury found present, the aggravating circumstances involving torture and a significant history of felony convictions involving the use or threat of personal violence. One or more jurors also found mitigation in the form of “mental illness, childhood physical abuse, [and] childhood sexual abuse.” Upon balancing, however, the jurors unanimously agreed that the aggravating factors outweighed the mitigation and, accordingly, returned the death verdict. This direct appeal followed, in which Appellant presented fifteen claims for relief. Finding no reversible error after review, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed Appellant's conviction and sentence. View "Pennsylvania v. Smyrnes" on Justia Law